“When Ignorance Becomes an Offence: The Quiet Confessions of an Unintentional Lawbreaker”
Have you ever unintentionally broken the law?

If we answer honestly—without the halo of self-righteousness—we may have to nod, however reluctantly. The law, like the air we breathe, surrounds us. It governs how we drive, how we pay taxes, how we build our homes, how we express ourselves, even how we forward a message on social media. Yet, like the air, we often notice it only when we gasp for breath.
I have often reflected upon this question, not merely as a citizen, but as an educator, a Principal once entrusted with discipline and decorum. And I confess—yes, there may have been moments when I crossed the invisible lines, not out of malice, but out of ignorance, haste, or misplaced assumption.
The Complexity of Law in Modern Life
In ancient India, the concept of Dharma—as elaborated in texts such as the Manusmriti—was not merely legal but moral and cosmic. Law was intertwined with righteousness. To violate Dharma was to disturb the harmony of the universe.
Contrast this with today’s legal frameworks—intricate, layered, and ever-expanding. In India, the Constitution of India is one of the lengthiest written constitutions in the world. It is comprehensive, yet its complexity means that even well-meaning citizens can falter unknowingly.
For instance:
– Parking in a no-parking zone “just for five minutes”.
– Forwarding an unverified message without realising it may violate provisions under the Information Technology Act, 2000.
– Missing a tax deadline by oversight.
– Using copyrighted material in good faith, unaware of infringement.
None of these acts may stem from criminal intent. Yet, ignorance, as the Latin maxim reminds us—ignorantia juris non excusat—ignorance of the law excuses no one.
The Slippery Slope of Convenience
Sometimes, we bend rules in the name of convenience. “Everyone does it,” we say. That dangerous justification has toppled empires and reputations alike.
History is replete with examples where minor ethical compromises snowballed into colossal consequences. In the Indian epic Mahabharata, a single act of moral blindness—when silence prevailed over justice in the Kuru court—ignited a devastating war. No one intended a holocaust at the outset; yet complacency and quiet complicity paved the way.
Unintentional lawbreaking often begins not with rebellion, but with rationalisation.
Between Law and Conscience
As someone shaped by Jesuit discipline and later entrusted with guiding young minds, I have often emphasised that character is what we do when no one is watching. Laws regulate society; conscience regulates the self.
Philosophers like John Locke argued that laws exist to preserve life, liberty, and property. But laws alone cannot create virtue. They can restrain misconduct; they cannot manufacture morality.
In schools, I witnessed students break rules unintentionally—uniform infractions, late submissions, minor mischief. Their defence was often, “Sir, I did not know.” Sometimes it was true; sometimes it was convenience dressed as innocence. The line between ignorance and negligence is often thin as a razor’s edge.
And perhaps the same applies to us adults.
The Digital Age: A Minefield of Invisible Laws
In our times, technology has added new dimensions. A careless click, a casual share, an emotional comment—these can cross legal boundaries instantly. We inhabit a world where the law travels faster than thought.
The digital citizen must be doubly cautious. The pen may be mightier than the sword, but the smartphone can be swifter than both.
As an author and blogger, I tread carefully. Intellectual property, defamation, privacy—these are not mere technicalities; they are ethical responsibilities. Words, once released, cannot be recalled like arrows mid-flight.
The Humility of Self-Examination
To admit that one might have unintentionally broken the law is not a confession of criminality; it is an acknowledgment of human fallibility.
We are finite beings navigating an infinite web of regulations.
Yet this realisation can be transformative. It urges us to:
– Read before signing.
-Verify before forwarding.
– Pause before reacting.
– Learn before judging.
It fosters humility.
Law as a Teacher, Not a Tyrant
Law, at its best, is not a whip but a compass. It directs rather than merely punishes. When we inadvertently err, the lesson lies not in fear but in correction.
In my 65 years of life, shaped by Nepalese childhood lanes, Indian constitutional values, and the disciplined corridors of boarding schools, I have learnt this much: breaking a law unintentionally should awaken awareness, not despair.
Mistakes are the tuition fees we pay to wisdom.
A Gentle Conclusion
Have I ever unintentionally broken the law? Possibly. In small ways, unnoticed perhaps. But each reflection refines the soul.
For in the grand courtroom of existence, the final judge is not merely the statute book—but our own awakened conscience.
Let us therefore walk carefully, not out of fear, but out of respect—for society, for justice, and for the unseen threads that hold civilisation together.
For the law may be written in books, but its true spirit must be engraved in the heart.





